Contemporary vs Traditional: Evolution of Gospel Music

Gospel music, firmly entrenched in African American religious experiences, has changed greatly from its origins in storefront churches to its current form, incorporating modern elements. Despite its growth, the genre keeps its essential spiritual aspects. The following sections will examine how Store Front Churches, Folk Spirituals, the Great Migration, Shout, Transitional Gospel Music, Speaking in Tongues, and Call-Response connect the traditional and current state of gospel music and contemporary gospel music.

Storefront Churches: The Birthplace of Traditional Gospel

In the early twentieth century, African Americans traveling to Northern cities sought spiritual sanctuary in tiny, informal worship facilities known as storefront churches. These churches were frequently built in abandoned storefronts in metropolitan locations, allowing congregations to worship in places they could afford. In these small settings, the raw, emotional essence of traditional gospel music thrived. The songs were emotionally charged, and participation was encouraged through a call-and-response format in which the crowd interacted directly with the preacher or choir.

Below is an example of Traditional gospel music. It is Thomas A. Dorsey’s Take My Hand, Precious Lord sung by Mahalia Jackson. Thomas A. Dorsey, known as the “Father of Gospel Music,” wrote this traditional gospel song. It was frequently performed in tiny, private church settings, where attendees sought consolation in profound emotional and spiritual connections.

As gospel music has progressed, storefront churches have given place to larger, more organized locations such as megachurches. Contemporary gospel is frequently performed in high-production settings with a greater emphasis on technology and professional musicianship. However, the emotional intensity persists, even if it is shown on a larger scale. An example of contemporary gospel is Tasha Cobbs Leonard’s Break Every Chain. 

This performance demonstrates how contemporary gospel has evolved into vast, professional worship settings while retaining the emotional fire that began in storefront churches.

Folk Spirituals: The Roots of Gospel

Folk spirituals, often known as “Negro Spirituals,” are the root of gospel music. These songs were composed by enslaved Africans in America, who combined African musical traditions with Christian themes. They were frequently sung a cappella, with basic, repetitive tunes and emotionally moving lyrics. The spirituals offered themes of hope, faith, and tenacity, which were frequently used as coded signals for escape and survival.

Traditional gospel music evolved from these spirituals, including instruments, intricate harmonies, and more organized lyrics. The ethos of the spirituals, characterized by raw emotion and profound faith, which remained important to gospel.

An example of a folk spiritual in a traditional gospel setting is Swing Low, Sweet Chariot. This rendition is sung by beautiful Etta James. 

Folk spirituals continue to have an impact on current gospel music, however they are frequently merged with modern genres such as R&B, hip-hop, and jazz. While the musical style has evolved, the teachings of hope and faith are eternal. Stomp by Kirk Franklin is an example of this amazing combination.
Kirk Franklin’s combination of gospel and hip-hop in “Stomp” channels the profound spiritual energy of folk traditions into a contemporary, urban sound, demonstrating how gospel’s roots can be adapted to current circumstances.

The Great Migration: A Cultural Shift in Gospel

The Great Migration (1916-1970) was a watershed moment in African American history, when millions of people relocated from the rural South to the metropolitan North in search of better economic prospects and to avoid Jim Crow restrictions. This movement had a significant impact on African American culture, particularly gospel music.

As African Americans moved to cities like Chicago, Detroit, and New York, their worship styles shifted to reflect metropolitan influences. This merging resulted in traditional gospel, which combined Southern spirituals with more organized Northern musical genres. The migration helped gospel music spread and flourish, influencing other genres including jazz, blues, and R&B. It also led to larger gospel choirs and more complex musical arrangements.

Mahalia Jackson’s How I Got Over exemplifies Southern influences on traditional gospel music. Mahalia Jackson’s music mirrored the spiritual depth of Southern traditions, but her gospel concerts in urban churches reached a broader, more diversified audience. She is the link between traditional Southern spirituals and the emerging Northern gospel movement.

Cultural fusion during the Great Migration also paved the way for contemporary gospel. The migration brought gospel into mainstream American society, providing the groundwork for the genre’s present fusion of modern pop, hip-hop, and jazz elements. Rev. James Cleveland’s God Is is one example of cultural fusion in transitional gospel.
James Cleveland is regarded as a pivotal character in transitional gospel music, transforming the depth of traditional gospel into a more modern, polished style that resonates in contemporary worship settings.

Shout: A Timeless Worship Tradition

The “shout” is an enthusiastic style of praise and worship that originated in African religious traditions and has now spread to African American religion. Unlike the “ring shout,” the scream is more freeform, incorporating spontaneous clapping, dancing, and vocal expressions of excitement during worship. In traditional gospel, the scream was an important aspect of expressing spiritual enthusiasm, frequently happening during tremendous musical build-up.

In old storefront churches, shouts would erupt as the assembly was stirred by the Spirit. This spontaneous style of praise stressed group involvement while allowing for intensely personal statements of faith. Below is an modern example of what a “shout” would be in traditional worship. 

Shouting is still used in contemporary gospel contexts, although it is more commonly integrated into the greater worship structure. While it remains powerful and spirit-driven, it may look more choreographed and polished, especially in bigger church settings or during concerts. William McDowell’s I Give Myself Away is a stunning example of a polished performance in modern gospel settings. McDowell’s performance includes times of intense spirituality in which worshipers respond emotionally and physically, similar to old shout settings, but in a more controlled, modern setting. I Give Myself Away is one of the most powerful performance of shout. 

Speaking in Tongues: A Charismatic Expression

Speaking in tongues, a prominent part of Pentecostal and charismatic worship, is regarded as a direct manifestation of the Holy Spirit. In historic gospel settings, particularly in Pentecostal churches, speaking in tongues was frequently accompanied by passionate worship, such as yelling and dancing. This method stressed the individual’s intimate, emotional relationship with the divine.

Speaking in tongues remains important in contemporary gospel, but it is frequently blended into worship music. In both traditional and modern contexts, this spiritual phenomena emphasizes the intensity and intimate aspect of gospel worship.

While speaking in tongues is not as prominent or common in today’s gospel, it is nevertheless revered in worship sessions, particularly in charismatic church settings. Tasha Cobbs’ Fill Me Up exemplifies intense worship and tongues. Cobbs’ song is a modern praise anthem with moments of speaking in tongues and contemplating.

Conclusion: A Dynamic and Living Tradition

Gospel music, whether traditional or contemporary, is a strong expression of religion, identity, and community for African Americans. While storefront churches and folk spirituals provided the groundwork for the genre, gospel has changed throughout time, responding to societal transformations caused by the Great Migration, technological advancements, and the mingling of musical genres. From the frenzied yells of early worship to the polished sounds of today’s megachurches, the foundation of gospel music has remained consistent: a profound, spiritual connection to God via song.

Elements like as the call-and-response framework, the shout, and speaking in tongues endure beyond generations, connecting modern gospel to its origins. Transitional gospel functioned as a bridge, and today’s musicians, such Kirk Franklin and Tasha Cobbs Leonard, continue to innovate while preserving the traditions set by pioneers like Thomas A. Dorsey and Mahalia Jackson.

Finally, gospel music’s power comes in its capacity to change while maintaining its spiritual and emotional foundation. Whether in the intimate quarters of storefront churches or today’s large auditoriums, the gospel is a living, breathing witness to the Black community’s perseverance, optimism, and faith. Its tale is one of continuity and evolution, reflecting the hearts and souls of both its artists and listeners.

Today, I will leave you with one of my favorite contemporary gospel artists, Tamela Mann. She is mutlitalented from being in Tyler Perry Madea films to singing and loving the Lord. 

Leave a Reply

What's your password?

Login to your account

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.